02.16.2023

#ESPN
#Sports
#ManipulatedContent

#ESPN
#Sports
#ManipulatedContent
02.16.2023
ESPN posted manipulated image of Joe Burrow after AFC Championship loss
Following the AFC Championship game on Jan. 29, sports news outlet ESPN shared a striking image to its official Twitter, Facebook and Instagram accounts that supposedly showed Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow watching the Kansas City Chiefs fans celebrating. However, the photo isn’t authentic — it’s manipulated. Let’s look at the facts.
Quick Look
- No
This photo — which appears to show Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow standing on the field after losing the 2023 AFC Championship game — is not authentic.
- Yes
It is a doctored version of a 2021 photo of Buffalo Bills player Stefon Diggs taken after his team lost that year’s AFC Championship game.
- Yes
ESPN published this doctored photo to its official Twitter, Facebook and Instagram accounts without disclosing that it wasn’t authentic.
The Takeaway
Accuracy is paramount to the practice of quality journalism, as is transparency. These standards, together with other guidelines like fairness and independence, distinguish legitimate journalism from other information we encounter online. This doctored photo of Burrow is certainly compelling — supposedly capturing the overall mood of his team’s AFC Championship loss — but it’s not accurate. Even worse, it’s intentionally incorrect. Purveyors of misinformation often use out-of-context and manipulated visuals that “feel true” to capitalize on emotional moments, but these tactics are flagrant violations of journalistic standards and ethics. This post, which hasn’t been deleted or corrected as of the time of this writing, raises questions about why ESPN posted it and whether the network took any steps to check whether it was authentic. RumorGuard has reached out to ESPN for comment. We have not yet received a response.
The 5 Factors
We’ve determined that this viral rumor is misleading or false based on its failure to pass the following credibility factors. Please note that these factors do not represent degrees of falsehood. A post that fails a single factor is generally just as false as a post that fails all five.
Snapshot
Authenticity
Source
Evidence
Context
- Reasoning
Is it based on solid reasoning?
N/A
The Techniques
Website
Tutorial: Reverse image search
The standards of quality journalism
Lesson
Practicing Quality Journalism
Website
Is it legit? Five steps for vetting a news source
Website